ASICS Women’s Gel-Excite 10 Review – Cloud-Like Comfort at $70

Between morning school runs and evening grocery trips, I desperately needed shoes that could handle my hectic mom life without leaving my feet screaming. When my old sneakers finally gave up after one too many playground chases, the ASICS Women’s Gel-Excite 10 caught my attention with promises of all-day comfort at just $70. Sarah here, and after juggling work deadlines, family activities, and weekend errands, I was determined to find something that wouldn’t slow me down. Eight weeks of real-world testing later, I discovered these shoes might just be the practical solution busy women have been searching for.

Technical Specifications

• 💰 Price: $70 ()
• ⚖️ Weight: 7.7 oz (women’s size 8)
• 📏 Heel-to-toe drop: 8mm
• 📐 Stack height: Regular cushioning profile
• 🧪 Midsole material: AMPLIFOAM PLUS technology
• 👟 Upper material: Engineered jacquard mesh
• 🏃‍♀️ Category: Neutral running/walking shoes
• 🎯 Best for: Daily walking, light running, all-day comfort
• ⏱️ Testing period: 8 weeks, 45+ wearing sessions, 200+ miles

Design, Build Quality & Real-World Performance

Right out of the box, the Gel-Excite 10 feels surprisingly substantial for a $70 shoe. The engineered jacquard mesh upper has this soft, almost sock-like quality that immediately caught my attention. Unlike some budget running shoes that feel plasticky or stiff, ASICS managed to create something that feels premium without the premium price tag.

The mesh construction is genuinely breathable – during those humid summer days when I’m running errands and my feet usually turn into swamp creatures, these shoes kept things surprisingly comfortable. The weave pattern isn’t just decorative either; it provides structure where you need it while staying flexible in key areas.

Upper Construction & Fit Experience

The toe box deserves special mention because it’s genuinely accommodating without being sloppy. As someone who’s dealt with the occasional bunion discomfort (thanks, genetics!), finding shoes that don’t squeeze or create pressure points is crucial. The Gel-Excite 10 provides that room to breathe while still feeling secure.

Lacing is straightforward with decent-quality eyelets, though I did notice the laces could be slightly longer for those who prefer a looser fit. The tongue stays put without sliding around – a small detail that makes a big difference during longer wear sessions.

Cushioning & Support – The “Walking on Air” Factor

Here’s where these shoes really shine, and why so many reviews mention feeling like they’re “walking on clouds.” The AMPLIFOAM PLUS midsole delivers a cushioning experience that genuinely surprised me. It’s not the ultra-soft, marshmallow feel of premium shoes like Hoka, but it’s substantial and responsive in a way that supports you through long days.

The rearfoot GEL technology isn’t just marketing speak – you can actually feel the difference when your heel strikes. It’s not dramatic, but there’s a noticeable softening of impact that becomes really apparent during longer walking sessions. Combined with the OrthoLite sockliner, my feet felt supported from the moment I slipped them on.

What impressed me most was how the arch support felt natural rather than intrusive. I don’t have particularly high arches, but I definitely notice when shoes lack proper support. These hit that sweet spot where your foot feels cradled without being pushed into an unnatural position.

On-the-Ground Performance

During my testing period, these shoes accompanied me through school pickup lines, grocery store marathons, weekend hiking trails, and even a few actual running sessions. The GUIDANCE LINE technology really does help with stride consistency – while it’s subtle, I noticed less fatigue during longer walking sessions compared to my previous shoes.

Traction on various surfaces has been solid. The rubber outsole grips well on wet pavement (tested thoroughly during Seattle’s rainy season), provides good stability on uneven sidewalks, and even handled light trail walking without slipping. They’re not designed for serious hiking, but for the occasional nature walk with the kids, they perform admirably.

Performance in Various Daily Conditions

All-Day Comfort Testing

The real test came during those inevitable 12-hour days that somehow become standard when you’re juggling family and work responsibilities. I wore these during a particularly brutal day that included morning errands, a full workday on my feet, afternoon school activities, and evening dinner prep.

By hour 8, I was impressed that my feet weren’t sending distress signals. By hour 12, I was genuinely surprised that I could still walk comfortably. This is where the Gel-Excite 10 really proves its worth – it’s built for endurance in a way that many similarly-priced shoes simply aren’t.

Weather & Environment Adaptability

The mesh upper’s breathability is a double-edged sword. During warm weather, it’s fantastic – my feet stayed comfortable even during those unexpectedly hot days when you’re stuck running errands in 85-degree weather. However, in colder or wetter conditions, you’ll definitely feel it. These aren’t weatherproof shoes, so plan accordingly.

I tested them during light rain a few times, and while the outsole provides good grip on wet surfaces, the upper will absorb moisture. They dry relatively quickly thanks to the mesh construction, but don’t expect them to keep your feet dry in puddles.

Does ASICS Deliver on Their Promises?

Marketing Claims vs. Reality

Claim: “Significantly lighter design than the previous version”
Reality: At 7.7 oz, these do feel noticeably light. Compared to bulkier athletic shoes, there’s definitely a sense of reduced weight fatigue during longer wear.

Claim: “More underfoot comfort for your run and fitness routine”
Reality: While comfortable for light running and fitness activities, these are really optimized for walking and daily wear. Serious runners might want more specialized cushioning.

Claim: “AMPLIFOAM PLUS provides lightweight cushioning and impact absorption”
Reality: Absolutely true. The cushioning strikes an excellent balance between responsiveness and comfort. It’s not ultra-plush, but it’s substantial and durable.

Claim: “Engineered mesh creates softer feel and improves breathability”
Reality: Both claims are accurate. The mesh is genuinely soft and breathable, though this comes with the trade-off of reduced weather protection.

Real-World Durability Assessment

Here’s where I need to be honest about the reviews I’ve seen and my own experience. After 8 weeks of regular use, I haven’t experienced the toe area holes that several reviewers mentioned. However, I can see how they might develop with more intensive use or specific foot shapes.

The areas of concern seem to be the mesh over the toe box and the side panels where the foot flexes most. For my usage pattern (mostly walking, light running, daily activities), the durability has been fine. But if you’re planning to use these for intensive daily running or have particularly aggressive foot mechanics, the durability might be a consideration.

My Overall Assessment

Detailed Performance Scoring

Comfort (9.5/10): Exceptional for the price point. The cushioning and support combination creates genuine all-day wearability that rivals much more expensive options.

Support (8.5/10): Good arch support and heel stability. The neutral design works well for most foot types, though those needing motion control might want something more specialized.

Durability (7/10): Solid construction overall, but some concerns about long-term mesh durability in high-flex areas. Perfectly adequate for casual use.

Breathability (9/10): Excellent ventilation through the engineered mesh. Feet stay comfortable even during extended wear in warm conditions.

Value (9.5/10): Outstanding value proposition. You’re getting features and comfort that typically cost $120+ in a $70 package.

Style (8/10): Clean, modern design that works with athletic wear and casual outfits. Multiple colorways available to suit different preferences.

Versatility (9/10): Excellent for walking, light running, gym workouts, and daily activities. Not specialized for any one activity, but competent across many.

What Other Women Are Saying

The feedback patterns from other users align closely with my experience. Healthcare workers consistently praise these for comfort during long shifts. Mothers appreciate the balance of support and style for daily activities. The most common positive themes are immediate comfort, excellent value, and genuine all-day wearability.

The most common complaints center around durability concerns, particularly holes developing in the toe area, and sizing running slightly large. Some users also noted they’re not ideal for narrow feet, as they tend to have a more accommodating fit.

Critical Considerations

These shoes work best if you:

• Need comfortable shoes for walking and light activity
• Spend long hours on your feet
• Want excellent value without sacrificing comfort
• Prefer a roomier toe box
• Need something versatile for multiple activities

Consider alternatives if you:

• Do intensive daily running (5+ miles)
• Need maximum weather protection
• Have very narrow feet
• Require motion control features
• Want maximum durability for rough use

Final Verdict

The Good and The Bad

Who Should Buy the ASICS Gel-Excite 10?

Perfect for:

• Healthcare workers and service professionals who need comfortable shoes for long shifts
• Busy parents juggling multiple daily activities requiring all-day comfort
• Casual walkers and light runners wanting good value without premium pricing
• People with foot comfort issues like plantar fasciitis or bunions needing accommodating shoes
• Budget-conscious buyers seeking maximum comfort value under $75

Better Options for Specific Needs

For serious running: Consider the ASICS Gel-Nimbus or Gel-Kayano series for more specialized running features and enhanced durability.

For maximum durability: New Balance Fresh Foam or Brooks Ghost series offer more robust construction for intensive use.

For narrow feet: ASICS Gel-Cumulus or Saucony models typically offer a more secure fit for narrow-footed users.

For weather protection: Consider shoes with more substantial uppers or weather-resistant treatments if you need year-round outdoor use.

Final Recommendation

The ASICS Women’s Gel-Excite 10 delivers exceptional value for women seeking comfortable, versatile shoes for daily activities. At $70, you’re getting cushioning, support, and build quality that punches well above its weight class.

While they may not be the most durable option for intensive use, they excel at their intended purpose: providing outstanding comfort for walking, light running, and all-day wear. For busy women who need shoes that won’t slow them down, these represent an excellent investment.

Overall Rating: 8.8/10

🛒 Get the best deal:

Frequently Asked Questions

Do the ASICS Gel-Excite 10 run true to size?

Most users find they run slightly large. Based on the reviews, many recommend going half a size down from your normal shoe size. If you typically wear orthotics or prefer a roomier fit, your true size should work well.

Are these good for plantar fasciitis?

Yes, many users with plantar fasciitis report significant comfort improvement. The AMPLIFOAM PLUS cushioning and OrthoLite sockliner provide good support, and the accommodating toe box reduces pressure points. However, for severe cases, you may want to add custom orthotics.

How long do these shoes typically last?

With regular daily wear (walking and light activities), users report 6-12 months of comfortable use. For intensive use or daily running, some experience wear issues sooner, particularly in the toe area. Your mileage may vary based on foot mechanics and usage patterns.

Can I machine wash these shoes?

ASICS recommends against machine washing. Several reviewers mentioned ruining their shoes by washing them. For cleaning, use mild soap, water, and air drying to maintain the mesh integrity and cushioning properties.

Are these suitable for wide feet?

Yes, these work well for wide feet. The mesh upper has some give, and the toe box is accommodating. Multiple reviewers with wide feet specifically praised the comfortable fit without feeling squeezed.

How do these compare to Hoka shoes?

While not as heavily cushioned as Hoka models like the Bondi, the Gel-Excite 10 offers excellent comfort at roughly half the price. They’re more versatile for daily wear and less bulky, making them better for mixed activities rather than specialized running.

What’s the weight difference compared to heavier athletic shoes?

At 7.7 oz, these are noticeably lighter than many traditional athletic shoes. Users consistently mention reduced foot fatigue, especially during long wearing sessions. The weight reduction doesn’t sacrifice cushioning quality.

Do they work for gym workouts and cross-training?

Yes, they perform well for general fitness activities, light weight training, and cardio classes. The neutral design and good lateral support make them versatile for various gym activities, though specialized cross-training shoes might be better for intensive lifting.

Review Scoring Summary

Get the best price on Amazon: