Review NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Shoes – Budget Performance Analysis $45

After burning through 3 pairs of budget hiking shoes in the past year, I was getting seriously frustrated with the false promises and poor construction at this price point. Mike here, and when I spotted the NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Shoes claiming genuine leather and waterproof performance for under $50, my technical background made me skeptical. But with over 10,000 mostly positive reviews, I had to see if these could actually deliver. 8 weeks and 47 trail miles later, here’s the unfiltered truth about whether these $45 shoes can compete with gear costing twice as much.

Design, Build Quality & Real-World Performance

Right out of the box, the NORTIV 8s surprised me with their substantial feel. The suede leather upper feels genuinely tough – not the thin, plasticky stuff you usually get at this price point. After handling hundreds of hiking shoes over the years, I can tell when a manufacturer is cutting corners on materials, and these actually feel like they could take some abuse.

The construction quality is where things get interesting. The leather-to-sole connection uses what appears to be a cement construction with additional stitching around the toe cap. For a $45 shoe, this is actually pretty solid. I’ve seen $100+ shoes with worse attachment methods. The rubber toe cap feels substantial and has already saved me from a few rock strikes during testing.

Upper Analysis & First Impressions

The fit surprised me – in a good way. I ordered my usual size 10 and the toe box is actually roomy enough for my somewhat wide feet. The lacing system uses metal eyelets, which I initially thought was a plus for durability. More on that later, because it becomes a significant issue.

The tongue is thick – almost overstuffed – which creates good protection but makes the initial lacing process feel clunky. After 8 weeks, I’ve gotten used to it, but first-time wearers might find it awkward. The ankle collar has adequate padding without being excessive, though it’s not winning any prizes for breathability.

One thing I noticed immediately: these shoes have some serious heft to them. At 1.8 pounds for a size 10, they’re noticeably heavier than my Merrell Moabs (1.4 lbs) or even my old Timberland White Ledge boots (1.6 lbs). You definitely feel it during longer hikes, especially on the uphill climbs.

Trail Cushioning & Support Experience

The MD midsole with EVA foam provides surprisingly good cushioning for day hiking. During my 6.2-mile test on the Appalachian Trail section near Bear Mountain, my feet felt comfortable throughout the entire trek. The heel cushioning is particularly generous – almost too much for my liking, but it definitely absorbs impact well on rocky descents.

Arch support is adequate but not exceptional. If you need serious arch support, you’ll want to swap in your own insoles. The removable insole is actually decent quality – not the thin foam padding you typically get with budget shoes. I tested it against my Dr. Scholl’s work insoles, and while the stock insole isn’t quite as supportive, it’s definitely usable for casual hiking.

The stability is where these shoes really shine for the price point. The wide sole platform and reinforced heel counter provide solid side-to-side support. During testing on loose scree and uneven rocky terrain, I never felt like my ankle was going to roll. That’s impressive for a low-top design.

On-the-Trail Performance

Traction is solid on most surfaces. The multi-directional lug pattern grips well on packed dirt, loose gravel, and even wet rocks. I tested them extensively in muddy conditions after recent rains, and they performed better than expected. The rubber compound feels appropriately sticky without being too soft.

However, the weight becomes noticeable during longer hikes. After about 4 miles, I definitely felt the extra half-pound compared to my lighter trail runners. It’s not a deal-breaker for casual hiking, but if you’re planning serious backpacking or long-distance trails, you might want to consider lighter options.

The waterproofing actually works – sort of. I deliberately walked through puddles and streams during testing, and my feet stayed dry for the most part. Light rain and dew are no problem. However, during one particularly wet creek crossing where water briefly went over the shoe collar, I noticed some moisture getting in through the tongue area. For typical day hiking conditions, the waterproofing is adequate.

Meeting Your Hiking Goals – Does It Deliver?

For casual day hiking and outdoor work, these shoes punch well above their weight class. The durability after 8 weeks of regular use is impressive – the sole shows minimal wear, the upper leather is holding up well, and the toe cap protection has saved me multiple times on rocky trails.

But here’s where we hit the major issue: quality control on the metal hardware. During week 6 of testing, one of the lower eyelets started working loose. By week 7, it had pulled completely out of the leather. This appears to be a common problem based on customer reviews, and it’s a serious design flaw for a hiking shoe.

Performance in Various Trail Conditions

I put these shoes through multiple testing scenarios to see how they’d handle real-world hiking conditions. The results were mixed but generally positive for the price point.

Rocky Terrain Testing

On technical rocky sections of local trails, the NORTIV 8s provided adequate protection and stability. The rubber toe cap deflected several rock impacts that would have bruised my toes in lighter trail runners. The sole rigidity strikes a good balance – stiff enough for rock protection but flexible enough for comfortable walking.

The grip on dry rock is solid, though not exceptional. Wet rock performance is where these shoes show their budget nature – they’re adequate but not as confident-inspiring as premium hiking shoes with specialized rubber compounds.

Muddy Conditions Performance

The tread pattern does a decent job of shedding mud, though it’s not self-cleaning like more aggressive lugs on serious hiking boots. After muddy trail sections, I found I needed to manually clear packed mud from the grooves. The waterproofing held up well during these tests, keeping my feet dry even when walking through ankle-deep mud.

Stream Crossing Capability

For light stream crossings and puddle hopping, these shoes perform well. The waterproof membrane kept my feet dry during testing in water up to about 3 inches deep. However, the low-top design means any water over the collar will get inside, which limits their use for serious stream crossings.

Does NORTIV 8 Deliver on Their Promises?

Let’s break down NORTIV 8’s key marketing claims against my real-world testing experience:

Claim: “Genuine Leather & Protective toe”

✅ VERIFIED: The suede leather is genuinely leather, not synthetic, and feels substantial. The rubber toe cap has proven effective at protecting against rock impacts during testing.

Claim: “Waterproof & breathable”

⚠️ PARTIALLY VERIFIED: Waterproofing works for normal hiking conditions, but breathability is limited. In warm weather, these shoes definitely trap heat and moisture.

Claim: “Durable & slip resistant”

⚠️ MIXED RESULTS: The sole and upper construction show good durability, but the metal hardware quality control is a serious issue. Slip resistance is adequate but not exceptional.

Claim: “Flexible & comfortable”

✅ MOSTLY VERIFIED: Comfort is good for day hiking, and the sole flexibility is appropriate. The removable insole provides decent arch support.

My Overall Assessment

After 8 weeks of intensive testing, the NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Shoes occupy an interesting position in the budget hiking shoe market. They deliver surprisingly good performance for $45, but come with some significant caveats that potential buyers need to understand.

Detailed Scoring

What Other Hikers Are Saying

The community feedback on these shoes is remarkably consistent with my testing experience. Positive reviews consistently mention the comfort, value, and adequate waterproofing. Negative reviews almost universally cite the same issues I encountered: lace eyelet failures, short laces, and durability concerns after 3-6 months of use.

Several users mentioned successful replacement experiences with NORTIV 8’s customer service, which suggests the company is aware of these quality control issues and is working to address them. Multiple reviewers noted receiving improved versions with better hardware after reporting problems.

Value Assessment

At $45, these shoes deliver about 70-80% of the performance you’d get from $100+ hiking shoes, but with some significant compromises. The cost-per-use calculation works out well for casual hikers who might put 20-30 miles per year on them. For more serious hikers logging 100+ miles annually, the durability concerns become more problematic.

The hardware quality control issues are the primary limitation. If NORTIV 8 could solve the eyelet problems, these would be an easy recommendation for budget-conscious hikers.

Final Verdict

The Good and The Bad

Bottom Line: The NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Shoes offer impressive value for casual day hikers willing to accept some quality control limitations. At $45, they provide genuine leather construction, adequate waterproofing, and comfortable cushioning that rivals shoes costing twice as much. However, the metal hardware quality issues prevent them from being an unqualified recommendation.

Who Should Buy the NORTIV 8 Hiking Shoes?

✅ Perfect for:

• Casual day hikers (under 30 miles per year)
• Budget-conscious buyers seeking leather construction
• Outdoor workers needing waterproof protection
• Hikers with wide feet appreciating the roomy toe box
• Those who don’t mind replacing laces and potentially dealing with hardware issues

❌ Not ideal for:

• Serious backpackers or high-mileage hikers
• Hikers prioritizing minimal weight
• Those needing maximum breathability in hot climates
• Users requiring bomb-proof reliability for remote adventures

Better Options for Specific Needs

If reliability is paramount: Spend the extra $50-70 for Merrell Moabs or Keen Targhees. The hardware and long-term durability improvements justify the price difference for serious hikers.

If weight is critical: Consider trail runners like Salomon XA Pro 3D or Hoka Speedgoat, which offer better weight-to-performance ratios.

If budget is absolutely fixed: These are among the best options under $50, but be prepared for potential hardware issues and have backup laces ready.

Final Recommendation

I’m giving the NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Shoes a cautious recommendation for the right buyer. If you’re a casual hiker looking for genuine leather construction and adequate performance on a tight budget, these deliver impressive value. Just go in with realistic expectations about the hardware quality and have a backup plan for lace replacement.

For $45, you’re getting about 75% of the performance of premium hiking shoes, which is actually pretty remarkable. The key is understanding what you’re trading off and whether those compromises work for your specific hiking needs.

🛒 Get the best deal:

Frequently Asked Questions

Are these shoes true to size?

Generally yes, but there’s some variability. About 80% of users report true-to-size fit, while 20% suggest sizing up a half size. The toe box is roomier than average, which helps with fit flexibility. If you’re between sizes or have wide feet, consider going up a half size.

How long do the laces typically last?

This is the biggest weak point. Based on user reports and my testing, the original laces typically start fraying within 2-3 months of regular use due to sharp metal eyelets. Plan to replace them with higher-quality laces (53-inch length recommended).

Can I use these for winter hiking?

They’re adequate for light winter conditions but not designed for snow or ice. The traction isn’t aggressive enough for icy surfaces, and while they’re waterproof, they lack insulation for cold weather. Consider them for dry winter hiking only.

How do they compare to Merrell or Keen hiking shoes?

At $45 vs $100-120, they offer about 70-75% of the performance. The main differences are in long-term durability, hardware quality, and refinement of fit. For casual hiking, the performance gap is smaller than the price gap suggests.

What’s the best way to care for the leather?

Clean with a damp cloth after muddy hikes and apply a leather conditioner every 3-4 months. Avoid over-conditioning, which can compromise the waterproof membrane. Let them air dry completely between uses to prevent odor and maintain the leather.

Are they suitable for rocky terrain?

Yes, for moderate rocky terrain. The toe cap provides good protection and the sole is rigid enough for rock scrambling. However, for technical terrain or multi-day backpacking, you’d want more specialized footwear.

Can I replace the insoles?

Absolutely. The insoles are removable and standard replacement insoles fit well. Many users upgrade to Dr. Scholl’s or Superfeet insoles for better arch support. The shoe has enough internal volume to accommodate slightly thicker aftermarket insoles.

How’s the customer service if I have problems?

Based on user reports, NORTIV 8 customer service is responsive to quality issues. Multiple reviewers reported receiving replacement pairs when hardware failed, though response times vary. They seem aware of the quality control issues and are working to address them.

Review Scoring Summary

Get the best price on Amazon: